Is it illegal to download movies/tv shows from file sharing sites such as Megaupload?

Is it illegal to upload or to download? I would have idea it was both, but there are sites with links to these media files and they arent being close downward. If downloading is illegal so what is the worst that tin can happen to the downloader?

Comments

  • I know sharing is illegal but I'm not sure about downloading to exist honest.

    The fact is people upload so many pirated videos all the time that the copyright holders probably have a hard time keeping up with it all.

  • Yes I'm pretty sure it's very illegal. So many people exercise it however and then barely anything always happens to downloaders. At the worst you would become a letter of the alphabet from your Internet service provider telling y'all to finish or they would cancel your internet connection.

    It's when you start profiting from it that they come up down tough on you, such equally making pirate DVD's from them etc. Hope that helps.

  • The illegality is in the distribution of the films there doesn't seem to exist an bodily police about receiving such downloads no affair how much people try to pretend there is.

  • 44444444 Posts: 1,104

    Forum Fellow member

    Do yous honestly recall that to ain certainly a picture you need non legally have been required to pay for it? :confused:

  • Is information technology illegal to upload or to download? I would have idea it was both, simply there are sites with links to these media files and they arent existence close down. If downloading is illegal and so what is the worst that tin happen to the downloader?

    Who cares? The internet is immense, the chances of you lot or I always getting defenseless (fifty-fifty downloading 50 gigs a month) are so small it's not even worth worrying.

  • The illegality is in the distribution of the films there doesn't seem to exist an actual police force about receiving such downloads no thing how much people try to pretend there is.

    I'd imagine it's covered in the copyright laws.

  • What well-nigh something like the wonder years which has never been released on dvd? Would that be illegal to download?

  • I'd imagine it's covered in the copyright laws.

    You'd imagine wrong the copyright law covers the distribution not the actual buying of a single re-create.

  • Who cares? The internet is immense, the chances of you or I ever getting caught (fifty-fifty downloading 50 gigs a calendar month) are and then modest it'due south non even worth worrying.

    When you hit your isp'due south dl cap im sure they will look into what information technology is you downloaded. You lot may become caught out here.

  • You'd imagine wrong the copyright law covers the distribution not the actual buying of a single copy.

    I notice it immensely hard to believe yous couldn't be done for downloading copyrighted films or TV shows, ane mode or another.

  • When you hit your internet service provider's dl cap im sure they will await into what information technology is y'all downloaded. Y'all may get caught out hither.

    rollox. Internet service provider's don't intendance anymore than you lot do. you only need to upgradte to faster line with no limit.

    You call back they give a shit about copyright laws?

  • Yeah information technology is, but y'all're unlikely to exist caught compared to uploaders.

  • I discover it immensely hard to believe y'all couldn't be washed for downloading copyrighted films or Tv shows, one way or another.

    Copyright police deals with one thing who's making the coin it's non set up up to deal with people sharing files, it is a stretch for it to prosecute people that are distributing without profit like torrent users it just hasn't got the laws to bargain with individuals who are downloading.

  • From here

    Restricted acts

    It is an offence to perform any of the following acts without the consent of the possessor:

    Copy the work

    Rent, lend or consequence copies of the work to the public.

    Perform, circulate or show the work in public.

    Conform the piece of work.

    Looks like I imagined right after all. Obviously in exercise 99% of the time you lot'd get off with a alarm, just the law equally information technology exists conspicuously tin utilise to downloaders.

  • Despite what some people volition tell, the act of just download is Not an offence, information technology MAY be an offence in certain circumstances (i,e. you intend to make information technology available for others).

    It becomes an offence if you intend to, or do distribute copyrighted fabric without a license, however it is even so a ceremonious affair unless you distribute for commercial proceeds, in which example it becomes a criminal offence.

    http://www.copyrightaware.co.united kingdom/download/documents/1132%20LAW%20FLYER_red.pdf

    Equally for your Internet access provider spying, no as that IS currently illegal for an ISP to do unless it has been requested to practice so by those authorised under RIPA (basically the police and security services). Your ISP is allowed to monitor internet traffic for the purposes of network management, and is complimentary to throttle or even block sure protocols (such equally blocking bittorrent) just they are Not allowed to view what you are downloading or what websites you browse.

    Still, all this may or may not change depending on what parts of the recently forced through without proper due process bill they decide to implement.

    FACT and the BPI are constantly lying to consumers when they tell you lot it is a crime, it is NOT unless it is for commercial gain.

  • stoatiestoatie Posts: 78,128

    Forum Member

    ✭✭✭

    Yup. It's illegal, only the chances of getting busted are minimal. Doesn't make it any more correct or whatever less wrong, but in terms of practicality it's an important consideration.

    However, 1 does know it's illegal, and so if one gets busted for it, one should not be calling the WAAAAAAAHmbulance, considering, well, that's the gamble one takes.

    *edit- just saw captainkremmen's mail- important to call up that while torrenting, you're both downloading AND uploading.

  • Despite what some people will tell, the human activity of merely download is Not an offence, it MAY be an offence in certain circumstances (i,east. you intend to make information technology available for others).

    It becomes an offence if you intend to, or practice distribute copyrighted textile without a license, notwithstanding it is still a civil thing unless you distribute for commercial gain, in which case it becomes a criminal offence.

    http://www.copyrightaware.co.uk/download/documents/1132%20LAW%20FLYER_red.pdf

    As for your ISP spying, no as that IS currently illegal for an Internet access provider to do unless it has been requested to practise so by those authorised under RIPA (basically the police force and security services). Your ISP is allowed to monitor internet traffic for the purposes of network management, and is gratuitous to throttle or even block certain protocols (such as blocking bittorrent) but they are NOT allowed to view what you are downloading or what websites y'all browse.

    Withal, all this may or may not modify depending on what parts of the recently forced through without proper due procedure bill they decide to implement.

    FACT and the BPI are constantly lying to consumers when they tell you lot it is a criminal offense, it is Non unless it is for commercial proceeds.

    Thanks for maxim it better than I could.

  • Despite what some people volition tell, the act of just download is Non an offence,

    ...yep, it is, if you're downloading a copyrighted work without the consent of the owner. Your link fifty-fifty says this. Downloading counts as "making a copy" just as much as their example of burning a DVD.

  • ...yes, it is, if you're downloading a copyrighted work without the consent of the owner. Your link fifty-fifty says this. Downloading counts as "making a copy" just as much as their instance of burning a DVD.

    No it says:
    "Downloading may exist unlawful and in some instances it will exist an offence if the intention is to employ the downloaded copyright cloth e.yard. films or music for unlawful purposes..."

    Unlike the law on kid pornography for case, just downloading does NOT count every bit making a copy under copyright police. The offence is committed depending on what yous so do with that downloaded film or music rail. Copy the downloaded file to a DVD-R so you would be committing the offence of "making", but again, unless there is commercial gain it is a civil offence. I am not aware of ANYONE in the Great britain who has been prosecuted simply for downloading copyrighted material, in fact the only cases that accept always gone to court have all been under "commercial gain", including torrent site owners prosecuted. The owner of Oink was prosecuted for distribution but the instance was thrown out as at that place was no evidence of commercial gain.

  • Offences
    A person commits an offence who carries out
    the following without the permission of the
    copyright owner:
    • making unauthorised copies eastward.g. burning films onto
    DVD-Rs

    Downloading is making an unauthorised copy, there's no two means about information technology.

  • Downloading is making an unauthorised copy, there's no two ways about information technology.

    No it isn't, unlike CP laws copyright police does NOT say downloading is making a copy. Peradventure information technology should, merely it doesn't.

    Why practice you call up NO ONE has always been prosecuted just for downloading?.

    Fifty-fifty companies like ACS:Law accept NEVER taken anyone to court for downloading.

  • I use rapidshare mainly, non as much stuff bachelor on megaupload.

  • No it isn't, different CP laws copyright constabulary does Non say downloading is making a re-create. Maybe it should, but information technology doesn't.

    It doesn't have to specifically mention every possible medium, the word "copy" is enough, in downloading you are making a copy. If it'south a copy of something copyrighted, and yous don't have the owner's consent, then you are breaking the law, information technology's equally elementary every bit that.

    I use rapidshare mainly, not as much stuff bachelor on megaupload.

    Truthful, just with their ridiculous changes of late, uploaders are fleeing from rapidshare in droves. It'southward crown will exist coming off very soon.

  • It doesn't have to specifically mention every possible medium, the word "re-create" is plenty, in downloading you lot are making a re-create. If it's a copy of something copyrighted, and you don't have the owner's consent, and then yous are breaking the constabulary, it's as uncomplicated equally that.

    True, but with their ridiculous changes of late, uploaders are fleeing from rapidshare in droves. It's crown will be coming off very soon.

    That is your opinion though. Fifty-fifty the copyright human activity states downloading MAY exist illegal. If it was ever illegal it would say "is illegal", but it does not do and so. I estimate nosotros volition merely have to disagree,